“Yeah, But…” Escaping the Mental Trap

Podcast: Play in new window | Download

In preparedness, your mindset is the foundation for every action you take. It can be the tool that ensures your safety or the trigger that invites disaster. As preppers, we often talk about having the right gear along with tactical and homesteading skills, but what happens when your own thinking becomes the biggest threat? This isn’t about complex survival scenarios. It can happen on any given morning when a simple decision goes wrong.

It’s easy to get locked into a false sense of “I’ve got this,” where you override your better judgment. This is the story of how that exact thing happened to me and how it ended with an unnecessary trip to the emergency room. More importantly, it’s a look at the “Yeah, but…” trap—a dangerous cognitive shortcut that can convince any of us to take foolish risks.

TL;DR: The “Yeah, But…” mindset is a mental trap that leads us to justify risky decisions despite knowing better. Recognizing it helps us make safer choices.

A Recipe for Disaster: The Morning It Went Wrong

1. Early Morning Realization

The day started before dawn. I woke up around 4:30 a.m. and, like every morning, my first stop was the front door to check the weather before getting ready to head to the gym. My yard and driveway were covered in about four inches of snow, with more falling at a steady, heavy pace.

2. The Gut Check

My initial thought was immediate, clear, and strong: Driving to the gym at 5:00 a.m., in the dark, on icy, unplowed, rural roads during a snowstorm was a stupid idea. There was no debate in my mind. “Yep, that’s dangerous,” I thought. “It’s not happening.” It was a simple, very apparent, and real risk. The risk outweighed the reward. My gut feeling and the winter facts aligned perfectly—no gym this morning.

But then, as I turned away from the door—my mind flipped.

 3. The Justification Spiral

The part of me that didn’t want to miss a workout staged a coup. The arch-enemy of sound judgment—the “Yeah, but…” mental terrorist, hijacked my thinking.

“Yeah, but I’ll be careful,” my new thought shouted in my head. “I’ll drive slow. And I have a full set of winter clothes, hand warmers, and a down blanket in the car, just in case. All I need to do is drive slow, don’t slam the brakes, and keep the wheels on the road. Too easy!”

While all those points were technically true, they didn’t change the fundamental reality: it was still a high-risk activity with a low reward that I could have achieved in other ways. I was planning to drive on mostly unplowed roads, hoping to follow someone else’s tracks, in an area where help would take a while to arrive if something went wrong. In conditions that weren’t very forgiving. I let the “yeah, but all I have to do is be careful” mindset completely overshadow my initial grasp of—it’s not a good time to drive into town if I don’t have to—reality.

It was my mental ‘Yeah, but” that started it all and paved the way for what came next.

Consequences of Shortcut Logic

As I began to head to the gym, I got to the end of my driveway, stopped my car, and decided to quickly step outside to pick up my trash can. It had been blown over by 60+ MPH winds the night before. Dressed in insulated rubber boots, gym shorts, a hoodie, and a ball cap, I opened the door and stepped out. As I did, my mind screamed at me that it was icy and I wasn’t dressed for the sub-zero wind chill. But again, that little voice piped up: “I just have to be careful. It’ll be quick.”

Here’s a hard-earned piece of wisdom: “quick” and “careful” rarely go together.

Because it was freezing and I was in shorts, “quick” turned into “hurry” before I got cold. In my rush, I pushed the trash can, which hit just right on a patch of ice. The can slid out, away from me, and flipped over, pulling me down with it. I landed, catching its hard plastic edge with the bottom of my chin—hyperextending my neck backward—before slamming my right eye into the edge. The impact rang my bell. As it was happening, and everything slowed down, I had the very matter-of-fact thought that I might be breaking my neck right now, and if I’m seriously injured, I would probably freeze to death and die next to my trash can.

I Rang My Bell

I wasn’t knocked out, and my brain definitely wasn’t firing on all cylinders. It took real effort to focus. Did I hurt myself? How bad? I needed to get out of the freezing storm before my exposed skin got frostbite. My first conscious thought was to check if I had broken my neck. I wiggled my fingers and toes. Everything was still connected and functioning. Then, I checked my face and felt the gash over my eye and the blood dripping down. I knew it would need stitches.

That’s when my brain cleared enough to register that my bare legs were in the snow and getting cold. It was time to start the not-rushing part of my morning. As I slowly got up, the sobering realization hit me again: if I had really injured myself and hadn’t been able to get up, there was a very real chance I could have died right there. Few people drive down my road at that time, let alone in a blizzard. I recognized just how stupid I had been—and how incredibly fortunate.

My downfall that morning began the moment I made that first “Yeah, but…” rationalization, putting safe, smart, and secure aside. My first instinct was the correct one. I was going to the gym, not to a job that I couldn’t miss. The workout could have waited. Had I listened to that initial, wise assessment, I never would have face-planted onto my trash can.

Understanding the “Yeah, But…” Cognitive Trap

My story is a textbook example of cognitive dissonance. This is the mental discomfort we feel when we hold two conflicting beliefs simultaneously. In my case, my beliefs were:

1. “Driving in these conditions is dangerous.”
2. “I really want to go to the gym.”

The “Yeah, but…” is how our brain tries to resolve this conflict. It minimizes the risk of justifying the desired action (“Yeah, it’s dangerous, but I’ll be careful”). It’s a coping mechanism that lets us proceed with a poor decision while feeling we’ve made a logical choice. We trap ourselves with our own excuses.

This happens in all areas of life, from justifying unhealthy habits (“Yeah, this cake is bad for me, but it’s been a long week”) to making questionable financial choices. In the context of preparedness, where stakes are often higher, this mental shortcut can have severe consequences.

Strategies to Defeat the “Yeah, But…” Mindset

Recognizing this flawed pattern is the first step to overcoming it. You can build practical habits to perform mindset checks and ensure that your decisions are grounded in reality rather than rationalizations.

1. Practice Self-Awareness and Pause

Your first instinct, that gut feeling, is often your subconscious mind processing vast amounts of past experience and environmental data. It’s a powerful survival tool. When you hear the “Yeah, but…” creeping in, stop. Take a moment to pause and acknowledge that your brain is trying to justify something. Ask yourself: “Am I trying to make the facts fit my desires, or am I making a decision based on just the facts?”

In my case, a simple pause could have allowed me to ask, “Is a workout worth the risk of a car accident or getting stranded?” The answer would have been a clear no.

2. Use Metacognition: Think About Your Thinking

Metacognition is the practice of observing your own thought processes in real-time. It’s like having a supervisor in your head monitoring your decision-making process. When you feel impatient, determined, or rushed, take note. These emotions often serve as a catalyst for the “Yeah, but…” trap.

By noticing these internal states, you can interrupt flawed patterns. You can consciously say to yourself, “I’m feeling rushed right now, and that’s leading me to cut corners. I need to slow down and reassess.”

3. Conduct a Fact-Based Risk Analysis

Emotions can cloud judgment. To counter this, run your decision through a simple, fact-based filter. Weigh the potential risks against the potential rewards. Be honest and objective.

• What is the potential upside? (e.g., I get a good workout.)
• What is the potential downside? (e.g., I could get in a car accident, get stranded in the cold, injure myself, or worse.)
• How likely is the downside? (e.g., Driving on icy, unplowed roads significantly increases the probability of an accident.)
• Is the reward worth the risk? (e.g., The reward of one workout is not worth the risk of serious injury or death.)

This simple process grounds your decision in logic and strips away the emotional justifications that fuel the “Yeah, but…” mindset.

The Bottom Line – Mindset Is Your Most Important Prep

Your mindset is the operating system for all your skills and gear. A resilient, flexible, and honest mindset allows you to adapt, solve problems, and maintain morale under stress. A flawed mindset, however, can undermine the best-laid plans and most expensive equipment.

By learning to recognize and challenge the “Yeah, but…” trap, you empower yourself. You trade false determination for calm confidence. You ensure your actions enhance your safety rather than endanger it. Take the time to check in with your mindset, especially when you feel that internal conflict. It might just save you an unnecessary trip to the ER—or something far worse.

Additional Resources